* It’s normal to just wave your arms around and cheer in delight several times during an hour-long television episode, right? Happens all the time?
* Big big cheer when I (finally? not sure how I stacked up vs. most viewers) realized what was happening with the narrative. I’d gotten pretty worried when we had that brief glimpse of an obviously distraught Don at a payphone in the middle of the night, asking Peggy if she’d gotten any calls in a cryptically unspecific fashion, hanging up in the middle of her mea culpa for the Heinz debacle. (I realize now that part of what worried me is that the last time I saw a quick cut to an alpha male at a pay phone we never saw him arrive at, telling a woman with whom he has a relationship rife with sublimated parental and romantic feelings about something bad that had happened off-screen, on a show Matthew Weiner worked on, I was watching a Sopranos episode called “Long Term Parking.”) But the next time we see Don he’s cheerfully rebuffing Roger’s attempt to turn a trip to an upstate Howard Johnson’s into an old-school Draper/Sterling debauch (Don: “I love Howard Johnson’s…” Roger: “We’ll try and stop by!”), inviting Megan along instead, so everyone I was worried about while watching that phone call — Don, Megan, Roger — seemed squared away. It wasn’t until the beginning of the third, Don-centric segment of the episode, when we saw conversations repeated from a different perspective, that I understood. And marveled!
* Peggy’s soundtrack was ambient. (Both ambient music and ambient noise — thank you, stereo surround system purchased for us by my college friends as a wedding present for the low bass thrum from the street below as Peggy had her first drink.) Roger’s was found music (including “I Just Wasn’t Made for These Times,” LOL MAD MEN MUSIC CUES). Don’s was traditional orchestral scoring.
* One of my little cheers was for me, I admit, for identifying the role of the color orange on this season early and often, just in time for a metric ton of payoff during the Howard Johnson’s sequence. “We’d have rolled out the orange carpet!” The battle of the orange sherbet! Those gorgeous, ridiculous HoJo-noir night shots against the glowing orange roof! Not since the Godfather movies has orange been such a portent of doom. It was easy for me to believe that something really had happened to Megan, that this was the last Don or we or anyone else would ever see of her, simply because she had a salmon dress on.
* Roger and Jane are advised to look at their acid trip as a boat ride. Don looks around the parking lot for Megan and finds a boat. (Pretty sure that was salmon-colored, too.)
* Roger’s trip (band name alert!) was maybe only the second-most Sopranos thing to happen in the episode, thanks to that Don phonecall, but god was it a great reminder of what made that show so great. Both shows give images the time to play themselves out and then leave you with them, little emotional depth-charges you might not even understand in the moment — lots and lots of shots of the women at the party lying down, crawling, faces obscured, just for example. Both don’t mind being frightening and silly within the same scene, or letting dream logic infect everyday reality. Neither is afraid of taking a message and punching you right in the face with it, because after all, sometimes you really do get punched in the face with a message about your life IRL. What, are they not gonna have Roger fixate on an old-young man in an ad, or reminisce-hallucinate about the Black Sox scandal in a way that makes him seem like a creature from a wholly different century than his young wife? If you were Roger, wouldn’t you?
* Speaking of silly-frightening drug stuff, I caught a heavy “Revolution 9” vibe from the sequence despite it predating that song by, what, two years? I mean, maybe it was just Don whistling “I Wanna Hold Your Hand” later in the episode — and jesus, how’s that for a pop-culture moment, Don Draper Meets the Beatles — that put me in mind of the comparison, but seriously: the full-blast snippets of grand orchestral music, the overlapping and disconnected conversations, the songs played one on top of the other, the occasional goofy sound effect — heck, eventually Roger and Jane became naked!
* Roger hears the words of his guide and sees Don. I think that’s a lot more complex a hallucination than the “haha he idolizes Don” sight gag suggests. He idolizes Don, he fears Don, he envies Don, he likes Don…but he also made Don. Don exists because Roger thought him up, essentially, saying okay, this guy has some talent, let’s see what he can do. The hallucination is, quite literally, a reflection of that reality. And since Roger’s the elder, he can never acknowledge any of these feelings, not to anyone else, not even to himself without the help of LSD, without violating a tremendous taboo against being less self-sufficient than the generation that follows you. That is some magnificent burrow-deep-down drug writing right there.
* I’d pretty much accepted the implication that Jane simply didn’t remember her decision to divorce Roger during the trip, but it occurs to me now — it’s just as possible Roger hallucinated her entire side of the conversation, isn’t it?
* The irony there, while we still have the dawn of Roger and Don’s relationship on our minds, is that it began under similar circumstances. The morning after their first liquid lunch, Don shows up to work, telling an amnesiac Roger that he hired him the day before.
* “I say we postpone this conversation until after we turn on.” I laughed hard at that.
* Shit, this is a sexy fucking show. Peggy’s movie-theater handjob may be top dawg. “Just watch the movie.” Yowza.
* Peggy awoken by the Dawn.
* Regarding the super-fake car rides: This is a show that could make car rides look convincing if it wanted to. This wasn’t them trying to shoot perfectly natural-looking car rides and failing.
* Ginsberg born in a concentration camp? This revelation dropped into the middle of a story about being a Martian from which he never breaks character, peppered with portentous quote-unquote jokes like not being able to find any others like him and receiving the instruction simply to stay where he is and wait? Peggy gets her Jewish reporter boyfriend to fact-check the story during a booty call — she’s nothing if not efficient — but it’s not Ginzo the person within this world I wonder after, it’s Ginzo the device within this show. Mad Men‘s just given him an origin story that echoes Don’s in nearly every particular — both orphans raised by a non-biological parent, both shaped by war in a formative way — but trumps it over and over. He’ll see your whore and raise you a Holocaust victim. He’ll beat your army-grunt identity switch by never having been known by his original identity. He’ll take your Korea and give you a World War Fucking II. Who is this guy?
* I’ve already talked a bit about how plausible Don’s morbid ideation about Megan’s post-fight fate were made to seem by the filmmaking in the episode, but of course the other half of that equation is that all of us have gone on similar flights of terrifying fantasy any time our significant other takes too long getting back from getting prescription filled or whatever. I’m pretty sure I don’t talk enough about Jon Hamm as an actor, but good lord did he nail the moment when he discovers their apartment’s been locked from the inside — that moment when some little thing, the tip of a vast iceberg of relief and gratitude, tips us off that our loved one is safe and sound after all. The shuddering release of breath, the momentary jellyfish-jiggle as your nervous system hits the “she’s okay” button as hard as it possibly can.
* This is why I think it’s a big mistake to view Don and Megan’s relationship as dysfunctional, at least as I understand it. Look at the way the fight ends, with Don clinging to her like a life raft — not to their life, not to the idea of her, not to what she represents as a signpost of the life he’s made for himself, but really to her, to this person named Megan. Look at the way her look and touch absolves him, accepts his apology, expresses regret as she comes to understand how upset he truly was. I don’t wish to deny how titanic and terrifying as the fight’s climax was, with Don chasing her around the apartment like a madman — that’s not romantic, that’s threatening, although I don’t get the sense that Megan felt truly in danger, just that she in that moment was horrified by the prospect of being close to Don at all. His actions “diminish” what they have, she says. They do not fight well, that’s clear; their fights are tied into the May-December sexual kink they share and thus can ricochet off in hugely inappropriate and hurtful directions (Don’s chase is just an ugly goes-to-eleven distortion of their earlier dom-sub shenanigans) unless the combination is calibrated exactly right. But the way even the nastiest, scariest, most rage-fueled fight dissipated into near-nothingness the moment they realized how hurt they both were rang very true. In that moment the immensity of their love dwarfed their anger at one another, so they just swatted it away. I don’t know if I’ve ever seen that depicted on film before.
Tags: Mad Men, reviews, TV, TV reviews
“it’s just as possible Roger hallucinated her entire side of the conversation, isn’t it?”
I don’t think so. Jane seems to confirm what her therapist said (that is, what Roger heard her say her therapist said). So I assumed that the conversation, despite her seeming to forget it, was real.
DerikB: Yeah, and as soon as she acknowledged that she remembered that part, her face looked like she was remembering the rest of it and then she went straight to asking whether the divorce would be expensive.
I thought it was perfect that Roger and Jane were on different pages there but only briefly. Jane, being Jane, would wake up feeling like she’d just had a wonderful experience and been relieved of a terrible burden, and she wouldn’t *want* to remember the details; it’d be so much nicer to think they had fixed their marriage. And we were left wondering for just long enough to realize how horrible it would be if Roger had imagined it all, just to reinforce what a huge thing it was for them to have really connected in that way.
I’ve been in almost that situation– two people in a relationship having totally different recollections of a really important conversation– without any drugs being involved, and it was really disturbing. So for me that moment was nearly as scary as Don chasing Megan around the apartment, another thing that went just far enough to let you imagine how bad it could have gotten.
As always, I enjoy reading your thoughts on this show.
Something else that stuck with me from last night until now: This is the third episode in a row where someone painfully/frighteningly faces some self-delusion and come out with an important truth. 1) Most everybody in “Mystery Date”–Joan finally axing her husband being my favorite example. 2) Pete and Lane in “Signal 30”. (And personally, I think that episode was Pete hitting his rock bottom and we will start to see some change in him soon… or he will just careen off a metaphoric cliff. Never know with this show.) 3) The three main characters in this weeks episode. My favorite being Roger. He is buoyant as he says the last line of the episode.
There was another suicide reference in this episode. I think this show’s wonderful enough to not just simply have a big SUICIDE moment later in the season but something heavily-laden with doom of the self-inflicted variety is on its way.
The awful moment where Megan shoves the Orange Sherbet in her mouth was also a subtle call back to the scene where Sally knocked over the milkshake in a similar diner in “Tomorrowland”. That’s the scene where we see Don fall in love with her. Now, we see Don trying to corrupt the very thing he found so remarkably different and free.
Both Roger and Joan are single. And they have a baby together. On any other show this would lead to a bunch of obvious story beats. But on Mad Men… I can’t wait to see how they confound expectation.
Those car rides: right on the nose with making them stylized on purpose. Though I can’t figure out exactly why except they look like old films. And what about the crossfades this season? What’s with the crossfades?
Man, I watched this episode late last night, just before I went to bed, and I ended up having the worst fucking nightmares about my own marriage….
Man, this episode. From the first glimpse of Don’s phone call to Peggy, I was on the edge of my seat. I knew something bad had happened. Every scene became a worst case scenario in the making — LSD overdose (that note!), car accident, kidnapping, domestic violence. Even before the narrative structure reveal, there was a sense of mounting tension that lasted until Don and Megan returned to the office. Definitely going to have to watch this one twice.
I also loved the fake-Instagramness of the car ride scenery — the image had all the color pop and grainy fidelity of a postcard you could have bought in that Howard Johnsons lobby.
Maybe I’m just being juvenile but Peggy’s boyfriend talks about an actor wrestling with a python in a movie, and then Peggy goes to a movie and…
I wonder if Weiner had any idea what an amazing character Peggy was going to be when he dropped her fresh little face into the pilot. Every one of her scenes this week just killed me dead. Even that Heinz presentation, which could’ve just come across as “Peggy commits a faux pas with jerky client”, felt wrenching because she was so effectively channeling Don Draper there– and we’ve been conditioned by all of the previous Don-versus-a-client scenes, as well as zillions of shows and movies about scrappy underdogs, to think that when the client says “Can you believe this girl?” he’s going to follow it up with some kind of concession because he’s so impressed with her ballsy honesty… but instead he just hates it, and her co-workers won’t back her up at all. And you can see that she understands exactly what the deal is: I thought it would work, it didn’t work, now I have to eat it.
I’ve read a lot of good reviews of the episode, but yours was the only one that described the Don/Megan relationship as I also see it: not doomed, not solely dysfunctional, but yes, a little desperate. I hope we see them continue to struggle… but make it. The series has already shown us Don Draper in a failed marriage. I don’t think it will repeat that.
Paul, you are literally the half-dozenth person to say this to me. So first of all, thank you very much! And second of all, all of you who agree with me about this, get out and shout it from the rooftops! Team Dongan!
Pingback: Mindless Ones » Blog Archive » Mindless Mad Men #5 – Far Away Places
Pingback: Mad Men thoughts index « Attentiondeficitdisorderly by Sean T. Collins