On his blog, Paul Pope has posted a quote from Frank “Dune” Herbert’s son Brian about how upset his father was over the (ahem) similarities between his work and George Lucas’s later, much more successful Star Wars. It got me thinking in a way that’s sort of in direct opposition to the way I’ve been thinking about a lot of art lately.
This is something I’ve gone into on the blog before: Basically, a sometimes-writer and a frequent consumer of fiction, I’m a very big fan of what I think of as “the art of enthusiasm”—the magpie approach of constructing your own little mythos or whatever based on elements of other stories that you really really enjoy. That’s why I like that the He-Man/Masters of the Universe toys and cartoons were an incoherent mish-mash of sci-fi, fantasy, pulp and superhero conventions; they just took everything awesome and jammed it together. That’s also why I like Kill Bill, or Scott Pilgrim, or The Immortal Iron Fist*, or Star Wars itself, and so on. And it’s not just fiction. The same principle probably applies to Bowie throughout his career, latching on to whatever music had him psyched at the time and then moving on when he felt like it, as well as really really sample-heavy late-80s/early-90s hip-hop. So on the one hand I’d say that a big part of the appeal of Star Wars is that Lucas took all the stuff he loved—Flash Gordon, Carlos Castaneda, Dune, the Fourth World, drag racing, Joseph Campbell, World War II dogfighting movies, 2001—and jammed it together. Of course the downside is when you appropriate from a specific-enough source that it’s recognizable, even if it’s in a different context or surrounded by enough other elements that it’s just part of a patchwork. It’s a fine line aesthetically and morally as well as legally. I think it’s likely that both sides are right—it’s a perfectly valid artistic approach, and it’s perfectly valid to be upset if it’s your work being appropriated.
My yapping aside, click the link to see a badass Paul Pope drawing of a Tusken Raider sandperson.
*Tom Spurgeon is right when he says the humor in the last two issues is a little cutesy and forced; I detect the hand of Warren Ellis forum vet Matt Fraction in that “I’m being ridiculous and I know it!!!!!1!!111!” tone. That aside, it’s a pretty great book.